Connect with us


Harry Potter: 10 Scenes That Foreshadowed Sirius Black Was Not A Death Eater

Though he’s made to seem like a villain, here are 10 moments that foreshadowed Sirius Black’s true intentions in the third Harry Potter film.

These days, it is hard to remember how fans ever could have thought that Sirius Black was the real bad guy in the third Harry Potter book and movie. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is the one story in the Harry Potter series that has the distinction of not featuring Voldemort as the antagonist in any form.

RELATED: Harry Potter: 5 Most Likable Characters (& 5 Fans Can't Stand)

He's not trying to build a new body, nor is he jumping from an old diary or even appearing in the flesh. In the third Harry Potter story, the presumed villain throughout is Sirius Black, godfather to Harry and best friend to James. Reviewing the plot now, though, everyone should have known Sirius was good all along.

10 The Motorbike

Though Sirius himself does not appear until the third book/movie Prisoner of Azkaban, he is mentioned in the very first chapter of the Harry Potter series. When Hagrid arrives at 4 Privet Drive, to meet with Professors Dumbledore and McGonagall, he is riding a flying motorcycle.

When Dumbledore asks where he got it, Hagrid mentions that "young Sirius Black' loaned it to him. If Sirus has really been a Death Eater and a murderer, why would he have loaned his bike to Hagrid to take Harry away? Why wouldn't he have just killed Hagrid and left with Harry himself?

9 The Discussion With Madame Rosmerta

When Harry finally hears the "truth," that Sirius turned his parents over to Voldemort as he was their secret keeper, the audience also hears more about Sirius. This is where fans learn that Sirius and James were best friends, that they were never apart, that their friendship was as close as close could be. It's also made clear that Peter Pettigrew sort of just tagged along after them. The real relationships, and problems, the boys might have had is highlighted right away.

8 Sirius Knew Where The Gryffindor Common Room Was

To attack the portrait of the Fat Lady, Sirius had to know where the Gryffindor common room was. To know where the Gryffindor common room was, he had to be a Gryffindor. Having not met Peter yet, fans would have only had Ron's words to go by. "There wasn't a witch or wizard who went bad who wasn't in Slytherin." With that information in mind, it should have been clear that Sirius could not possibly have been a Death Eater.

7 No Students At Home

Sirius attacked the portrait of the Fat Lady on Halloween night. The books mention that this is very lucky, as, due to the feast, the dormitory would have been empty and no students would have been harmed had Sirius actually made it inside.

RELATED: Harry Potter: The Worst Thing About Each Hogwarts Teacher

It wasn't just luck. It should have been clear that this was deliberate timing, since Sirius was not a Death Eater or trying to kill Harry, and he only wanted to go after Scabbers when no one else was in the way.

6 Stands Over Ron

In the books, Sirius returns to Gryffindor Tower, makes it inside—using passwords written down by Neville—and then is caught standing over Ron's bed with a knife. Ron's yelling wakes the tower, and Sirius flees. The assumption is that Sirius picked the wrong bed and was looking for Harry. However, when looking back on the scenario, it's clear he purposefully was looking for Ron to find Scabbers/Pettigrew. He was never a Death Eater out to kill Harry at all.

5 "Where is He, Sirius?"

In the books, when Lupin appears on the scene in the Shrieking Shack, he asks Sirius where someone is. As Lupin obviously knows Harry—as well as Ron and Hermione—he can't possibly be asking about Harry at all. Lupin knows and is showing the audience that Sirius is after someone and something, else. Sirius was never a Death Eater and, in this last moment before the big reveal, the audience is being clued in.

4 Watched Quidditch

In the books, the "grim" shows up in the Quidditch stands as Harry is in the middle of a match. He isn't just seeing things; Sirius has taken time out of his vendetta to watch his godson play Quidditch. He doesn't attack or interfere. He only sits. This foreshadows the fact that the grim is not merely an imagined omen as well as the fact that Sirius, when fans find out he is the black dog, was not out to kill Harry by any means necessary.

3 The Newspaper

In the books, the minister of magic, Cornelius Fudge, mentions having visited Azkaban and having spoken to Sirius, who seemed to still have his wits about him. He even gave Sirius his copy of the Daily Prophet. The newspaper that had the picture of Ron's family's trip to Egypt.

RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Villains Who Deserved Harsher Consequences

The picture where Scabbers was sitting on Ron's shoulder. Sirius had his wits, which certainly meant something significant since the Dementors weren't having a full effect on him. The picture of Scabbers would obviously lead to his breakout from prison, not Harry.

2 "He's at Hogwarts"

In the books, fans learn that, soon after Fudge's visit to Azkaban, Sirius begins mumbling in his sleep. What does he begin to mumble? "He's at Hogwarts. He's at Hogwarts."

While Fudge and readers alike are supposed to assume this means Harry, the fact is Harry had already been at Hogwarts for a few years, and Sirius had only begun mumbling recently—right after Fudge gave him the newspaper and Sirius saw the picture of Scabbers with Ron in Eqypt..

1 Friends with Crookshanks

It's much clearer in the books than the films, but Sirius, in his dog form specifically, was very well-liked and assisted by Crookshanks. Though this upset Ron further, Hermione always insisted that Crookshanks was not only a good cat, but a smart cat.

Crookshanks knew who and what Sirius was long before anyone else. It would have been good to trust the animal instincts of the pets around them, and perhaps Harry, Ron, and Hermione would have understood the truth about the escaped Sirius Black much sooner had they done so.

NEXT: Harry Potter: 10 Ways Ron Got Worse and Worse

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Movies4 weeks ago

The Little Mermaid is the Absolute Worst

In the wake of Frozen 2’s $1 billion haul, the debate rages on about who is the best Disney princess...

Movies2 months ago

The 30 Best Movie Trilogies of All Time

What makes a good trilogy? Well, for starters, you have to follow the same theme throughout the entire series —...

Pop Culture2 months ago

18 celebs that were on TV before becoming Movie Stars

Everyone knows that movie stars get more love than the actors on tv. Why is that? Perhaps there is truly...

Movies3 months ago

Best Female Leads in Horror Film History

From “Scream Queens” to “Final Girls” the female role has continued to evolve in the horror genre, no longer are...

Movies3 months ago

10 Overlooked Movies of the 2010s

The 2010s was a solid decade for cinema. Even with a rise of remakes, creators didn’t shy away from innovation....

TV3 months ago

10 Times Someone From Jackass Should’ve Died

As America entered the 21st Century, man reached an evolutionary peak once thought unattainable. With the invention of personal internet...

Movies3 months ago

Slow to Fast: All 9 Fast & Furious movies ranked from worst to best

Fast and furious. There are no two words that have meant so much in cinematic history. Love it, or hate...

Pop Culture3 months ago

10 Most Underrated Shows of the 2000’s

It’s a new decade in this 2020, which means we’ve said goodbye to so many shows, and we’re saying hello...

Movies3 months ago

20 Films That Will Have You Reaching For Tissues

Sincerely, how good does it feel after you weep uncontrollably? Is it wrong to find pleasure in undergoing melancholy from...

Movies3 months ago

10 worst movies with a Star-studded cast

Even the brightest stars cannot hope to lighten up the darkest nights. That goes to say that even if a...